'There's one thing no one tells you about being the second wife.'

If you want to support independent women's media, become a Mamamia subscriber. Get an all-access pass to everything we make, including exclusive podcasts, articles, videos and our exercise app, MOVE.

I love him. But sometimes, being his second wife feels like being the understudy in someone else's story.

There's an obvious reason why being the second wife can be hard. Because it feels like coming second. Like you're the runner-up in a race you didn't even know you were competing in. And who doesn't want to be first?

First love. First wedding. First baby. First everything.

But I'm not his first. I never will be. Instead, I'm the woman who came after the storm. The one who picks up the broken pieces and tries to build something whole.

Watch: There are common mindsets women have towards dating when coming out of a toxic relationship or divorce; here are 3 dating mistakes women make after divorce. Post continues below.

I married the love of my life — but along with his love, I inherited his pain. His past. His wounds. No matter how much healing he's done, she's still there. The ex. The first wife. Not just a chapter in his story, but a character who still shows up in ours.

I found the photos once — buried deep, while planning our wedding. The suit he wore. The smiles. The guests. That brief chapter of his life, captured and preserved. A reminder that I wasn't his first bride.

With me, the celebrations were quieter. The excitement was more subdued. Not because the love was less — if anything, it was more — but because people had already seen him do it once. Some hesitated to "make a big deal" this time around, as if love can only be pure the first time it happens.

His first marriage lasted five months. Five months.

Not even long enough to settle in, and maybe not even really count. But long enough to do damage.

She was emotionally manipulative. Controlling. He lost his voice in that relationship — his confidence, his sense of self. When we met, he was still piecing himself back together.

They share a daughter — a beautiful, sweet little girl. The one good thing that came from that marriage. And I love her. I truly do. But I'd be lying if I said she wasn't also a reminder of what came before me.

First child. First time becoming a father. Not with me.

So when I had our first baby — when I finally became a mother — I carried something that no one talks about. A quiet grief. Our first wasn't his first. And even though he tells me it's different now, that it's better now because it's with someone he truly loves... the ache is still there. That little voice whispering: I wish it had been us the first time.

And still, the past shows up — sometimes literally, on our driveway. She lets herself into our space. Opens our car door. Acts like she still owns a piece of him. And maybe she does, in some strange way. They share a child — and with that comes a lifetime of negotiations, compromises, and constant reminders.

My husband once asked me to stay inside during pickups — not because he didn't want me there, but because he didn't want to give her a reason to start something.

It feels like I'm living with a ghost I can't exorcise. She still calls him "my ex-husband," like he still belongs to her. She thinks she can set boundaries in our home. Tells us what our routines can be, what her daughter can and can't do here. I've even been told not to call myself her step-mum — in case I "replace" her. But I have learnt, for the sake of my family, to set boundaries with her. To protect what is ours. I didn't sign up to live in someone else's shadow.

But here I am. Trying to love him through the remnants of a life he no longer wants, but still has to carry.

So, yes — being the second wife can be hurtful.

It means the "firsts" have already happened.

It means people might be less excited the second time around.

It means your wedding might be smaller. Your first pregnancy might be less celebrated.

It means being judged for things you never did, and having to prove — silently, endlessly —that you are not her. That he is not making the same mistakes. But, there's a silver lining. Because when you are the second wife, you get something rare.

You get a man who has learned.

He knows what love is not. He's seen the cracks that form when you choose the wrong person. And this time, he chose with intention. He chose me — not in the rush of young love or the pressure of doing what's expected. He chose me after the storm. After the healing. After the hard lessons.

I remember once, someone told me: "Get your first marriage over with, so your second can be with the love of your life."

At the time, I laughed. It sounded cynical. But now? Now I think there's truth in it. Because I see the way he looks at me — not with obligation, but with certainty. With gratitude. With relief. And maybe our love doesn't have all the "firsts" that his first wife had. But it has something stronger: Depth. Choice. Resilience.

Listen: This episode is all about divorce and separation—when it might be the right choice, what typically leads to it, and how to navigate it in the healthiest way possible. Post continues below.

I'm not the first. But I'll be the last. And maybe — just maybe — being the second wife doesn't mean he got it wrong the first time. It means he finally knew what it felt like to get it right. Because this time, love isn't rushed or reckless. It's deliberate.

There's something breathtaking about being loved by someone who has known the difference — someone who chooses you not because they're searching, but because they've found peace in your presence. This time, love feels like coming home.

It's quieter, but deeper. Softer, but unshakeable. And in his eyes, I'm not the second choice. I'm the best one he's ever made.

Feature Image: Getty Images.