Nobody Wants This season 2 fixes what season one got wrong.

Nobody Wants This is back for its highly anticipated second season, and after the whirlwind romance of season one, we're now diving into the messy, beautiful reality of what comes next. 

Season one gave us the fairytale meet-cute between Rabbi Noah and podcast host Joanne — complete with all the complications of an interfaith romance.

But it wasn't all smooth sailing — the season built to a crescendo where Noah's congregation and family pressured him about Joanne's reluctance to convert to Judaism. 

In the season finale, we watched Noah make the ultimate romantic gesture… running after Joanne to confess his love for her. The couple decided to stay together despite the unresolved conversion question hanging over their heads — a decision that felt both romantic and realistically complicated.

Watch the trailer for Nobody Wants This season 2. Article continues after video.

Now, season two grounds us in the reality of making that choice work long-term. The honeymoon phase of "love conquers all" is giving way to the practical questions that can't be indefinitely postponed.

Noah and Joanne are navigating the tricky waters of combining their worlds — bringing together friends and family, grappling with the conversion question that's still very much on the table, and figuring out how to merge two very different lifestyles.

At its heart, Nobody Wants This is a charming show that understands the power of small moments, and season two is no different. The writing is packed with tiny details and authentic touches that make every scene feel lived-in and real.

The way couples actually talk to each other, the little rituals they develop, the inside jokes that form naturally, the small miscommunications. It's this attention to authentic detail that elevates the show beyond typical rom-com territory for me.

Image: Netflix

This season feels much more like a true ensemble piece, with each character getting proper development and screen time. It's no longer just the Noah and Joanne show — everyone gets their moment to shine. And I love that.

Perhaps the biggest improvement is Esther's character development. After facing criticism in season one for being a stereotypical portrayal of a Jewish woman — with the seemingly one-dimensional nagging and mothering — the writers have given her real depth and complexity. She's funny, she's relatable, and is fast becoming one of my favourite characters in the show. 

Esther and Sasha are also having their own relationship recalibration, working through what kind of future they want together whilst dealing with the lingering awkwardness of his friendship with Morgan. But the show has smartly moved away from the will-they-won't-they tension between Sasha and Morgan that dominated season one.

For me, one of season one's biggest issue was Noah being almost too perfect. And this season corrects that imbalance beautifully. We're finally seeing Noah's red flags — his people-pleasing tendencies, his "golden retriever boyfriend" energy that can tip into love-bombing territory, and his inability to communicate when there's actually a problem. For me, it made him more human and the relationship more believable.

Leighton Meester's appearance as the insufferable influencer "Abby Loves Smoothies" is also pure gold. Seeing Blair Waldorf and Seth Cohen share screen time again is a millennial dream come true, and Meester nails every single influencer trope with perfect comedic timing. 

Image: Netflix

The show excels at capturing those universal relationship moments — the miscommunications, the small gestures that mean everything, and the challenge of maintaining romance when real life gets in the way. These are the issues every couple faces, regardless of their religious differences.

One thing I would fix about the season is how repetitive it felt at times, particularly between Joanne and Noah. We hear them have the same conversations over and over, tackling similar issues around faith, family expectations, and cultural differences — and while these are fleshed out beautifully, it does start to feel cyclical.

I found myself wanting them to move past the constant back-and-forth about conversion and commitment. Instead, I wish we would have spent more time with other characters like Morgan. We don't know enough about her — she's this brilliant, sharp character who deserves her own storylines beyond being Joanne's sister.

There's so much potential there that feels unexplored, and it would have been refreshing to dive deeper into her world rather than watching Noah and Joanne rehash the same fundamental incompatibilities for the third time.

Overall, season two successfully builds on what made the first season special whilst addressing its weaknesses. By giving us a more balanced portrayal of both Noah and Joanne's flaws, fleshing out the supporting characters, and grounding the romance in realistic relationship challenges, it proves that this show has staying power beyond the initial spark.

The series continues to handle interfaith relationships with nuance and respect, showing both the genuine challenges and the beautiful possibilities when two different worlds collide. It's funny, it's heartfelt, and it feels authentically messy in all the right ways.

Nobody Wants This season two doesn't just avoid the sophomore slump — it elevates the entire series.

Feature Image: Netflix.