'I tried 5 plumping lip glosses so you don't have to. These are the ones that work.'

Want to support independent women's media? Become a Mamamia subscriber and get an all-access pass to everything we make, including exclusive podcasts, articles, videos and our exercise app, MOVE.

Filters, fillers or just a great gloss? There's more than one way to boost a pout these days.

Personally, I still love the quick fix of a topical lip plumper. They're non-committal, comparatively affordable and (depending on the formula) can span everything from a nourishing daily balm to a spicy, high-powered gloss.

Watch: The best makeup palette you can buy right now. Post continues after video.

You'll often find me with one (or six) in hand at any given time. Yes, I'm that person who doesn't feel complete until my lips are glazed, tingling and that little bit more pronounced.

In pursuit of achieving the most plumped pout possible, I've tested five of the most-hyped formulas on the market right now.

(FYI I tested each formula on separate days. For consistency, all the before and after images were taken 20 mins after application.)

Some delivered subtle plumpness with nourishing benefits. Others? Full-scale spice.

From the high-fashion sheen of Gucci Beauty to the TikTok-beloved burn of VT Cosmetics, here's how they measured up.

1. Gucci Beauty Plumping Lip Gloss.

Image: Supplied.

In true Fran-form, I had start with Gucci (it just felt right!!). I've actually been using this formula for years – I love layering it over my MAC lipsticks.

Gucci Beauty Gloss A Levres Plumping Lip Gloss is formulated with menthol, ginger and cayenne pepper to boost lip volume, hyaluronic acid for moisture and their signature black rose oil to smooth fine lines.

As for results, the brand claims a 22 per cent increase in lip volume and 43 per cent hydration in user tests. Impressive.

My Gucci Beauty Gloss before and after results. Image: Supplied.

On first swipe, it's buttery, luminous and very glam. The shine is mirror-like but not heavy and the tingle is gentle (and only lasts 20 minutes). It also reads a little more like a minty hot than a spicy hot.

After 10 minutes, there was modest swelling at the lip edge and lips looked more pillow-y. I opted for the tinted shade Bertha Pink, which gives lips a beautiful flush.

In my experience, Gucci is best when you want a luxe, wearable gloss that gives a soft lift and keeps lips smooth. I wouldn't say this formula gives me the most drastic results, but I do see an improvement and the overall finish is plump and juicy.

2. BARRY M That's Swell XXL Lip Plumping Gloss.

Image: Supplied.

The BARRY M That's Swell XXL Lip Plumping Gloss surprised me.

The scent was the first thing I noticed; sweet and a bit synthetic. Not my personal cup of tea, but I could see it as something others might enjoy.

The texture is the real standout for me here. It's quite slick and reminiscent of a lip oil. It was lightweight and wore very comfortably on the lips.

The before and after using BARRY M That's Swell XXL Lip Plumping Gloss. Image: Supplied.

The tingling was far milder than I expected from something called "XXL." A gradual warmth built over about five minutes. Nothing drastic. And honestly, neither were the results. Moderate tingling, moderately plump.

There was slight rounding at the edges and lift through the centre of my bottom lip, but it wasn't what I'd be expecting from an XXL plumper.

Still, it's not a total pass. The finish is dewy, and it wears well for about 45 minutes before fading into a sheer, flattering sheen.

I didn't see major plumping over time, but my lips stayed hydrated and smooth. I'd opt for this on days when I want something low-key and gloss-like.

3. NYX Duck Plump Lip Gloss.

Image: Supplied.

NYX Professional Makeup Duck Plump Lip Gloss is both viral and volatile.

Beloved by Cardi B, this pigmented, plumping gloss touts "instant and overtime plumping" with a ginger root extract.

I found the texture of this one interesting. It's a slightly thicker, moussey gloss. It's very pigmented and lacquers onto lips nicely. The finish is sheeny and supple.

As for the burn? She's POTENT.

My NYX Duck Plump before and after results. Image: Supplied.

The heat on this one was pretty notable, with intense stinging for 30 minutes and up to two hours of a slightly more manageable tingle.

Silver lining, it was one of the longer lasting glosses. The colour and sheen lasted well into the evening.

I do think it flattered and gave some visible fullness, but not without paying the price. I wasn't overly impressed with the volume it gave, relative to the burn.

I would only reach for this on days I want drama and can tolerate the burn.

4. VT Cosmetics Reedle Shot Lip Plumper Expert.

Image: Supplied.

VT's Cosmetics Reedle Shot Lip Plumper Expert is not for the faint-lipped.

You may have seen this infamous K-Beauty "needle gloss" on your TikTok For You page. It's viral – and with good reason. I haven't experienced a plumping formula quite as powerful and impressive before.

It uses something called micro-spicule technology (tiny silica needles, essentially) to create temporary channels in the lips, supposedly boosting absorption of its plumping ingredients. Wild, I know.

My VT Cosmetics Reedle Shot Lip Plumper before and after results. Image: Supplied.

Within 30 seconds, the burn hit – sharp, hot, and intense.

My lips flushed red and felt sensitive to the touch, like I'd just eaten something way too spicy. It was borderline burn-your-lips-off pain, but.... the plump was real.

Especially in the centre, my lips looked noticeably fuller. The finish is ultra-glossy lacquer (almost wet-looking). For the first hour or so, it gave serious volume.

After that, things softened. The shine faded, and some of the swell settled down, but what stuck around was a smooth, slightly blurred texture that I really liked.

I wouldn't wear this every day, but for a night out or a bold moment? It absolutely delivers. Just be ready for the intense heat.

5. Maybelline Lifter Plump Plumping Lip Gloss.

Image: Supplied.

Maybelline Lifter Plump Plumping Lip Gloss bridges cult gloss and plumper.

The formula is dosed with hyaluronic acid, capsicum (chili) extract and Maxi‑Lip™ peptides to deliver both immediate heat and a plumping effect over time.

On the lips it's creamy, slick and sheeny. The pigment is pretty sheer (read: next-to-none) but it does look glassy and supple.

My Maybelline plumping gloss before and after results. Image: Supplied.

As for the plumping? The heat came up in waves, stronger in the initial minutes, then mellowing.

I felt light burning at the lip edges. The plump effect was subtle, though I did notice slight improvements to the upper and outer edges.

In my experience, the effect lingered for maybe 1 to 1.5 hours before softening. After that, a sheer tint remained.

This is a great middle ground: spicy enough to know it's working, but not so extreme that it's brutal.

For more tried and tested beauty recommendations, listen to the You Beauty podcast or watch You Beauty on YouTube.

At Mamamia, we independently curate and write about products we rave about in our group chats and think you should know about too. If you purchase a product we have recommended, we may earn a small commission.

This article originally appeared on Adore Beauty's Beauty IQ and has been republished with full permission.

Feature image: Supplied.